Courts test AI filings, digital evidence, and confidential data

New decisions and guidance address AI hallucinations, public-AI privilege risks, cross-border intercepts, WhatsApp evidence, and AI-training claims.

Edition
eDiscovery Decoder Newsletter

Sent November 16, 2026

Lead story

Delaware court sanctions lawyer for AI hallucinations

The Delaware Court of Chancery ordered a lawyer to pay $2,500 after an answering brief included AI-generated inaccuracies that were not verified.

What happened
The Delaware Court of Chancery ordered a lawyer to pay $2,500 after an answering brief included AI-generated inaccuracies that were not verified.
Why it matters
Written AI policies do not replace matter-level controls. Litigation teams need a review record showing that cited authorities, quotations, procedural facts, and record references were checked against primary sources before a filing is signed and submitted.
Watch
The sanction addresses counsel's verification failure in a particular Chancery Court matter; it does not prohibit generative-AI use in Delaware practice.

Sourcesaboutblaw.comnews.bloomberglaw.com

Briefing item

Public AI use raises privilege and disclosure risks

Current arbitration guidance warns that placing client documents, legal advice, prompts, or litigation material into public AI services can create confidentiality, privilege, and disclosure consequences.

What happened
Current arbitration guidance warns that placing client documents, legal advice, prompts, or litigation material into public AI services can create confidentiality, privilege, and disclosure consequences.
Why it matters
Discovery and investigations teams should distinguish public services from controlled enterprise systems, document the applicable retention and training settings, and prevent confidential material from entering unapproved tools. Collection plans may also need to identify prompts, outputs, access logs, and related AI-governance records when those materials bear on a dispute.
Watch
This is practitioner guidance reported from a panel, not a new court ruling. Privilege and disclosure outcomes depend on the governing law, the information submitted, the platform's technical and contractual controls, and the circumstances of use.

Sourcesscconline.com

Briefing item

Italian court excludes untestable Sky ECC intercepts

A court in Catanzaro excluded intercepted Sky ECC messages where defendants could not access and test the underlying electronic evidence, contributing to 34 acquittals in a 50-defendant prosecution.

What happened
A court in Catanzaro excluded intercepted Sky ECC messages where defendants could not access and test the underlying electronic evidence, contributing to 34 acquittals in a 50-defendant prosecution.
Why it matters
Cross-border digital evidence needs more than a transferred dataset. Counsel should identify the raw source, collection method, metadata, transformations, gaps, preservation authority, and a practical mechanism for independent testing before intercepted or forensic data becomes central to a case.
Watch
The report says the ruling does not create binding precedent. The decision arose in an Italian criminal case, and its treatment of Sky ECC evidence depends on the record, cross-border procedure, and absence of corroborating evidence described in the report.

Sourcescomputerweekly.com

Briefing item

Karnataka court requires review of withheld WhatsApp evidence

The Karnataka High Court set aside a customs adjudication order after authorities failed to address a request for WhatsApp messages, screenshots, and the associated electronic-evidence certificate.

What happened
The Karnataka High Court set aside a customs adjudication order after authorities failed to address a request for WhatsApp messages, screenshots, and the associated electronic-evidence certificate.
Why it matters
When an agency or litigant relies on messaging evidence, production workflows should preserve the messages, screenshots, surrounding context, source information, and required authentication records. Addressing access and admissibility at the outset reduces the risk that an adjudication must be repeated later.
Watch
The High Court did not decide that the WhatsApp material must be produced or rule on its ultimate admissibility; it required the adjudicating authority to consider those questions first.

Sourceslivelawbiz.com

Briefing item

Ontario court keeps publishers' OpenAI suit in Canada

The Ontario Court of Appeal dismissed OpenAI's jurisdictional appeal, allowing Canadian publishers' copyright case over alleged use of news content for AI training to proceed in Ontario.

What happened
The Ontario Court of Appeal dismissed OpenAI's jurisdictional appeal, allowing Canadian publishers' copyright case over alleged use of news content for AI training to proceed in Ontario.
Why it matters
AI-training disputes can require discovery into collection locations, crawlers, source datasets, model-development records, corporate roles, terms of use, and where relevant acts occurred. The jurisdiction ruling keeps those evidence questions in a Canadian proceeding governed by Canadian law.
Watch
The allegations remain unproven. The appeal addressed jurisdiction rather than copyright liability, fair dealing, damages, or whether the challenged copying occurred in Canada.

Sourcescp24.comtechtimes.com

Educational only. Not legal advice. Review sources and matter-specific obligations before relying on any workflow decision.