A federal judge in Tennessee has left a $45,763 attorney-fee award in place against Reaves Law Firm and its CEO, Henry Reaves III, over repeated faulty citations and nonexistent quotations. Chief U.S. District Judge Sheryl H. Lipman denied their request for reconsideration on November 17 and clarified the legal grounds for holding both the firm and its signing lawyer responsible. Court opinion
What the court found
The order described citations to cases that did not support the asserted propositions and quotations that did not exist. It said these problems appeared to result from suspected generative AI use, while noting that the firm had not acknowledged AI’s role in drafting the filings. The misconduct findings concerned the filings and the firm’s response after notice; the order does not identify a particular AI product. Court opinion
The firm and Reaves sought to vacate or modify the fee award, challenge personal liability and clarify whether the firm was being sanctioned as a party, a law firm or both. The court found no basis for reconsideration under Rule 54(b) and the local rule. It also recounted that the firm failed to respond to Baker Donelson’s fee submission even after the court gave it additional time. Court opinion
The clarified grounds
Lipman clarified that the award rested on Rule 11, Local Rule 83.4 and the court’s inherent authority, with an additional basis under 28 U.S.C. § 1927 for Reaves personally. She found that repeated reliance on fake citations after notice amounted to bad faith and disrupted the litigation. The firm and Reaves remained jointly and severally liable under the other grounds; § 1927 applied to Reaves alone. The amount remained $45,763, despite Baker Donelson’s request to raise it to $60,000. Court opinion
Analysis: Verification and the response to notice
For lawyers using AI in research, the practical lesson is to verify both what a cited case says and whether a quotation exists before filing, and to address identified errors directly. This ruling concerns repeated misconduct and the response to court notices. It does not establish a fixed penalty for AI use, and its several sanctions grounds should not be treated as interchangeable. Court opinion
Case status
In a separate November 17 order, the same judge dismissed Baker Donelson’s remaining counterclaim without prejudice and said judgment would be entered separately. The November 18 CourtListener docket inventory lists that judgment, but its text was unavailable. This report therefore does not characterize the judgment’s terms, payment status or any subsequent appellate proceedings. CourtListener labels the two orders’ precedential status as unknown. Court opinion
AI-assisted reporting based on court records retrieved through CourtListener. This reporting is produced by eDiscovery Decoder and is not reviewed or endorsed by Free Law Project.